The Best OTC Pain Reliever for Every Kind of Ache
Did you know that the best OTC pain reliever for your throbbing headache may not be the best for soothing sore muscles after a rigorous workout? Or that what works best for a fever is not the best medication for the joint pains of arthritis? Here, how to choose the best type of medication for your specific aches and pains.
Make the right choice
When you have aches and pains, you probably have lots of choices in your medicine cabinet. But all pain relievers aren’t created equal. Some work better for headaches or back pain, while others are stronger when it comes to fever or arthritis. Don’t just reach for the closest medication. Here’s the best over-the-counter pain reliever for every kind of ache.
The best OTC pain reliever for: Headache
Ibuprofen (Advil, Motrin) is a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug, or NSAID, that works to reduce inflammation. If you have a headache, ibuprofen is an effective treatment option, although if you are pregnant or prone to ulcers, you may want to choose another pain reliever. A 2017 study published in the journal Australian Prescriber suggests that people with a history of peptic ulcer disease, increasing age, and high-dose and long-term use of NSAIDs are at the highest risk of major gastrointestinal toxicity. Instead, take acetaminophen, which does not reduce inflammation, but sends a message to pain receptors. (If you’re prone to headaches, avoid these 12 foods that can make your headaches worse.)
The best OTC pain reliever for: Fever
Acetaminophen (Tylenol) is the optimal pain reliever for regulating the body temperature and relieving any aches and pains that come with a fever, says Kavita Gupta, DO, medical director of the Advocare Pain Institute of South Jersey. It is also considered the safest medication for children. While acetaminophen does not cause stomach irritation, it should not be used by those who drink alcohol regularly, adds Dr. Gupta. If you are taking acetaminophen, make sure to drink more water than usual as these pain relievers can dehydrate and tax the kidneys. One more caveat: Many combination medicines—Sudafed, Excedrin, NyQuil, and Alka-Seltzer Plus, for instance—contain acetaminophen. Taking these medicines when you’re already taking acetaminophen may cause you to get more than a safe amount of the pain reliever. (Check out these 6 hidden dangers of common over-the-counter pain relievers.)
The best OTC pain reliever for: Backache
If your back hurts after heavy lifting or other physical exertion, consider naproxen (Aleve). This NSAID differs from pain relievers like ibuprofen and aspirin in that it takes longer to work, but its pain-relieving effect lasts longer, making it the better choice for deeper aches and pains, says Dr. Gupta.
You could also try an over-the-counter transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) device (Aleve Direct Therapy TENS). It works by electrical nerve stimulation that can block pain receptors and trigger your body to release endorphins, your body’s natural pain blockers. However, pregnant women and people with pacemakers or epilepsy should avoid TENS as they may experience complications, suggests a 2020 review of studies published in StatPearls. (Got back pain? Here are 5 exercises that can make it better.)
The best OTC pain reliever for: Menstrual cramps
To alleviate the pain of menstrual cramps most effectively, your doctor may recommend an NSAID like ibuprofen or naproxen. A review of studies published in 2019 in Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care found that NSAIDs are more effective than acetaminophen at relieving period pain. Take the pain reliever at the beginning of your period, or as soon as you feel symptoms, and continue taking the medicine as directed for two to three days, or until your symptoms are gone. If you are still in pain, speak with your doctor about other treatment options or try one of these 8 unexpected ways to alleviate cramps.
The best OTC pain reliever for: Arthritis
Ibuprofen helps to relieve symptoms of arthritis (osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, or juvenile arthritis), including swelling, stiffness, and joint pain. “Ibuprofen stops inflammation, which is what leads to pain,” notes Dr. Gupta. It doesn’t cure arthritis, however, and will help alleviate pain only as long as you continue to take it. (Check out these 23 science-backed natural home remedies for arthritis pain relief.)
The best OTC pain reliever for: Exercise recovery
If you experience muscle aches and pains after a tough workout, naproxen may be the best pain reliever to address them. Much like backaches, these pains require a longer-lasting treatment, says Dr. Gupta. Just be aware that the pain relievers may also cause stomach upset, so take them sparingly. (Check out this primer on painkillers.)
The best OTC pain reliever for: Toothache
A review of research published in 2018 in The Journal of the American Dental Association suggests that NSAIDS—in particular, ibuprofen—offer the best balance between risks and benefits for acute dental pain, compared with opioid analgesics. Read more about 11 home remedies for a toothache.
- UpToDate: “Patient education: Nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) (Beyond the Basics)”
- Australian Prescriber: "Peptic ulcer disease and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs"
- Kavita Gupta, DO, medical director of the Advocare Pain Institute of South Jersey
- StatPearls: "Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation (TENS)"
- Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care: "Period pains: Can anti-inflammatory drugs help?"
- Acetaminophen Awareness Coalition: "Common Medicines Containing Acetaminophen"
- The Journal of the American Dental Association: "Benefits and harms associated with analgesic medications used in the management of acute dental pain"