H1N1: A Report Card on the Swine Flu Pandemic of 2009-2010
This report sheds light on the swine flu pandemic of 2009-2010 and the lessons we can learn from it.
From April 2009 to April 2010, the swine flu infected more than 60 million people and killed more than 12,000 in the United States. The Healthy is rerunning this article from the March 2010 issue of Reader’s Digest because of the light it can shed on the coronavirus outbreak. So far, the Covid-19 outbreak has infected 130,000-plus people worldwide and killed nearly 31 people in the U.S., but experts believe that we’re just at the beginning of the pandemic.
Arthur Allen, author of Vaccine: The Controversial Story of Medicine’s Greatest Lifesaver, talked with Kathleen Sebelius, who served as the United States Secretary of Health and Human Services from 2009 to 2014. In this article, Sebelius speaks about the flu virus variant H1N1, the pandemic it triggered, and about efforts to make a better flu vaccine. Related: If you haven’t got your flu shot yet, there’s still time.
Reader’s Digest: What have been our biggest successes and failures in handling H1N1?
Former Secretary Kathleen Sebelius: We went from identifying the virus to producing the first vaccine in less than six months. That’s pretty unheard of! We’ve been enormously successful at distributing the vaccine—over 60 million people have been vaccinated so far. With childhood vaccinations, we have 40,000 sites for distribution. We went from that to over 100,000 sites to try to get the vaccine to where states identified it was most needed for priority populations. That has gone extremely well. The production glitches have been a bit frustrating.
RD: Do you think the decision not to use an adjuvanted vaccine should be revisited? [A vaccine adjuvant is a substance that’s added to increase the response of the immune system. Because the vaccine is more powerful, less of it is needed. At the time, there had been relatively few studies on adjuvanted vaccines, but the technology is very much a part of the coronavirus vaccine development process.]
RD: Well, the dilemma that we were in here in the United States is that an adjuvanted vaccine had not been licensed for use. There had never been clinical trials in children. And what we were looking for was the safest and fastest pathway to a vaccination program. So it made sense for us to use the technology that was tried and true, and to use the pre-existing licenses that were already in place for seasonal flu vaccines. But I think one of the lessons that will be learned from H1N1 is: What are the clinical results of vaccinations with adjuvants now going on all around the world? Nobody—including countries in Europe, which have used adjuvanted vaccines for adults—have ever used adjuvanted vaccine for children. [Don’t fall for these vaccine myths that could compromise your family’s health.]
RD: You recently took part in the ribbon-cutting for a new Holly Springs, North Carolina factory that will produce cell culture-based flu vaccines as early as 2012. Do you think cell culture vaccines will help? [Most flu vaccines are produced using fertilized chicken eggs, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. During the 2019-2020 flu season, there was one cell-based flu vaccine approved: Flucelvax Quadrivalent.]
KS: That plant is a big deal for two reasons, not the least of which is that it brings manufacturing capacity back to the United States. That’s a significant step forward—we’re not so reliant on production elsewhere. During the current epidemic, two companies had to fill orders in their own countries before they could make the vaccines available to us. Secondly, cell-based culture doesn’t necessarily speed the growth time, but it is more reliable. Once the growth is there, you have a yield that is much more stable than with egg-based technology. It isn’t a silver bullet, but egg-based technology is 50 years old and we need to get to a variety of approaches that could be used in the future. So the investments need to continue: What are the alternative growth strategies? What else should we be looking at? [The Holly Springs vaccine factory is currently involved in the search for a coronavirus vaccine.]
RD: We’ve all heard about healthy people who come down with H1N1 and are dead within a few days. Are you satisfied with the medical response to this disease?
KS: Well, the data is puzzling, and I think a bit troubling, in that we know that about a third of the kids who have been seriously ill or died do not have underlying health conditions. And it’s the same with 25-year-olds and up; we don’t still quite understand why those over 65 seem to have a lot of resistance to this particular virus. [The opposite seems to be true of Covid-19.] I think it’s going to take a while for the scientists to figure this out—what exactly is going on with this disease. While there have been some recent reports that the vast majority of cases have been relatively mild, what the scientists are quick to say is that the severe cases are more severe than many of them have ever seen. I mean, the penetration is more rapid, it’s more devastating, it fills the lungs. So, yes, it’s pretty mild most of the time, but when it’s bad it’s really bad. But what exactly it is that triggers that, we don’t know. The group that has underlying health conditions isn’t so hard to understand. But the group that does not have underlying health conditions and moves from total health to a ventilator in two days, which has been the case too many times with younger people—that, I think, still needs to be understood.
RD: As this was being rolled out we heard about strains on public health departments. Has that affected the government’s response?
KS: The lack of resources means people have had to add more duties with fewer folks. But our coordination has worked tremendously well, and it fact we have learned a lot that will prepare us for the future, whether for the next pandemic or for other kinds of public health emergencies.
RD: What can be done about public mistrust of vaccines?
KS: There are groups out there that insist that vaccines are responsible for a variety of problems despite all scientific evidence to the contrary. We have reached out to media outlets to try to get them to not give the views of these people equal weight in their reporting to what science has shown and continues to show about the safety of vaccines. [We can learn these five important things from history about flu prevention.]
RD: I’ll just close by asking if there’s something you would like to add.
KS: Well, I think one of our challenges is to make sure that people understand that what we saw a second wave of H1N1. We have an opportunity to get out ahead of what easily could be a third wave. There are a lot of scientists who feel that if we’re successful and if we continue the vaccination program into the new year and get as many people vaccinated as possible, we really might avert what various experts believe may be a more vicious strain in the later winter months when flu season is really underway. [By May 2010, the pandemic was in steep decline, reported the World Health Organization.]
RD: So a lot of people think that it could be worse?
KS: In some other epidemics, there was a spike and then a milder spike, and then a big jump. And nobody knows if that might be the pattern with this virus. But there’s a window where we’re going to have a vaccine and, hopefully, the disease will have peaked. And that gives us an opportunity to continue to reach out.
- Johns Hopkins University: Coronavirus COVID-19 Global Cases
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: “The burden of the influenza A H1N1pdm09 virus since the 2009 pandemic”
- Harvard Medical School: "Designing a Coronavirus Vaccine"
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: “2009 H1N1 Pandemic (H1N1pdm09 virus)
- Kathleen Sebelius, United States Secretary of Health and Human Services, 2009 to 2014
- World Health Organization: Pandemic (H1N1) 2009 - update 100