Why You Need to Talk to Your Doctor Before You Start Taking Supplements

Updated: Apr. 06, 2021

Thinking of starting a new supplement routine? Talk with your doctor or pharmacist first before popping a pill.

Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.

Before you start shopping for or taking supplements, it’s important to know that not all supplements are created equally. This is because the pills are not regulated by the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) in the same way as prescription medicines and conventional foods. “Supplements may carry harmful risks such as inaccurate dosing information and contaminated ingredients,” says Wendy Kaplan, MS, RDN, a dietitian in Long Island, New York.

That’s why smart supplement shopping is so important. “If you’re not sure about the safety of an ingredient, the first thing you should do is talk to your doctor or pharmacist,” notes John Travis, a senior research scientist at NSF International, a global public health and safety organization. “Also look for an independent certification mark on the label before you start using the product.” Examples of such certifications include ones from NSF International and the United States Pharmacopeial Convention.

Other resources exist to help you shop smartly. CVS Pharmacy has a “tested to be trusted” program for the supplements it sells. The program requires that all supplements sold at the store have undergone third-party testing to verify the accuracy of ingredients and also to confirm that products are free from certain additives and ingredients. And ConsumerLab.com runs reviews of the top-rated supplements in many supplement categories. Here are additional reasons to chat with your doctor or pharmacist before you start taking supplements.

cropped shot of woman holding supplements and glass of waterSorrorwoot Chaiyawong / EyeEm/Getty Images

Your doctor may recommend a blood test

Self-diagnosing isn’t necessarily the best strategy. If you’re pregnant, it makes sense to take a prenatal vitamin. However, not everyone needs to supplement with vitamins such as vitamin D or vitamin B12. “A supplement, just from the word itself, is meant to supplement or augment any vitamin or mineral you might be lacking or not having enough of,” says Robert Segal, MD, cardiologist and founder of Medical Offices of Manhattan in New York City. “Your doctor can recommend a blood test to find out which (if any) vitamins or minerals you may have deficiencies of.” A nurse practitioner or pharmacist can also order these same blood tests, too. (Be sure to check out the best and worst supplements to take if you’re diabetic.)

You want to get the intel on supplement benefits

“Ongoing research shows some supplements can have striking health benefits,” says William Li, MD, author of Eat to Beat Disease. “For example, a supplement formulation called AREDS may reduce the risk of vision loss from a condition called age-related macular degeneration. Fish oil supplements containing omega-3 fatty acids can lower risk factors for heart disease, and supplements containing prebiotics and probiotics are looking like they may be future game-changers for health as we begin to understand how our gut microbiome defends us against chronic diseases.” Discuss your specific health concerns and family history with your doctor. Then find out the probiotics brands nutritionists trust the most.

Supplements may have unproven claims

“Some dietary supplements make claims that are either not well substantiated or have no data to back up the specific claim,” says Marilyn Schorin, PhD, RDN, a dietitian in Louisville, Kentucky. “Some claims are very vague—such as helping brain health or boosting immunity—so your perceived benefit may vary substantially from the studies used to support the claim. Your doctor or health professional can help to sort the benefit from bluster.” Registered dietitians tend to be especially schooled in supplement knowledge, and you can find one in your area using the “find an expert” tool at EatRight.org. These are the anti-aging supplements doctors trust the most.

Your doctor may want to chat about family history

“It is not a good idea to just add supplements without discussing with your doctor and knowing what you need,” says Melissa Altman-Traub, MS, RDN, a dietitian in Jamison, Pennsylvania. “For example, if a person feels tired and decides to take an iron supplement to treat that, she may not know if she has a hereditary condition that causes her to absorb more iron and accumulate it. The excess iron could cause organ damage, and the original cause of the fatigue would go untreated.” Learn the nutrients even nutritionists don’t get enough of.

Certain supplement ingredients may be dangerous

“Many supplements have complicated names, and some potentially dangerous ingredients are listed under names that make them seem like safer, natural products,” says Travis. “For example, harmful compounds such as DMAA, DMBA, and DEPEA have been deceptively labeled as botanical extracts like geranium oil and dendrobium extract.” DMAA, for example, is an amphetamine that can cause health problems as serious as a heart attack, according to the FDA. See the vitamin brands doctors trust most.

Supplements may contain fillers that don’t agree with you

It’s common to look at a supplement but not the filler ingredients it contains. These ingredients may be problematic for certain people. For instance, they may contain inactive ingredients that pose a risk to someone with celiac disease. “It’s important for people to remember that not all supplements are created equally, and there can be added fillers, sugars, or other ingredients in supplements in addition to what you think you are taking,” says Nicole Avena, PhD, assistant professor of neuroscience at Mount Sinai School of Medicine, in New York City. “This is why it is important to review the ingredients list of any products you plan to take with your doctor to ensure that all are safe and won’t interact with anything in your personal medical history.”

Woman taking pills for her healthRawpixel.com/Shutterstock

You may end up taking in toxic levels

It may sound like a great idea to take a supplement such as vitamin A. But your body stores the fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, and K—and you can easily overdo it. “Certain supplements may contain excessive amounts of vitamins and minerals, and if taken every day they can accumulate into toxic levels,” says Allie Hosmer, MS, RDN, a dietitian in Washington, D.C. Minerals can also accumulate in your body.

You must take precautions before surgery

Having surgery in the near future? Disclosing your supplement regimen to your doctors and surgical team is critical. This is because certain supplements may increase your risk of bleeding during surgery. This list includes gingko biloba, milk thistle, and turmeric, according to the Stanford University School of Medicine. Your doctor will likely tell you to stop taking such supplements a certain amount of time before surgery. Here are more things to do before surgery.

Supplements and meds may interact badly

Because dietary supplements are mainly sold over the counter, it is very easy to start and stop dietary supplementation without your doctor’s knowledge,” says Sophia O. Tolliver, MD, MPH, family medicine physician at The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, in Columbus, Ohio. “Depending on the complexity of your health history, you could be at risk for medication interactions with unknown dietary supplementation.” Case in point: If you’re taking the blood thinner Warfarin, your doctor may advise against taking vitamin A, vitamin E, or garlic supplements. These can thin the blood—and when coupled with Warfarin, may make bleeding more likely, notes Dr. Li.

Interactions may make you feel icky

Even if you’re taking a short-term medication, such as an antibiotic, let your doctor know about your supplement routine. Here’s an example: “Combining magnesium and an anti-hypertensive medication could potentially have added effects, making a patient lightheaded, dizzy, or even faint,” says Lauren Tessier, ND, a naturopathic physician in Waterbury, Vermont. See the supplement or medication combos you should never mix.

Supplements may make meds less effective

“St. John’s Wort is often hailed its use with depression,” says Joan Salge Blake, EdD, RDN, a nutrition professor at Boston University and host of the health and wellness podcast SpotOn! “Unfortunately, this supplement can weaken the effects of many medicines, including crucially important ones such as birth control pills.” Many, many other potential interactions exist—for instance, vitamin K can counteract warfarin, notes Adam Splaver, MD, a cardiologist in Hollywood, Florida. So always give your doctor a full list of every single medicine and supplement you take, even if you take them infrequently.

You could land in the emergency room

More than 23,000 emergency room visits per year are linked with negative effects from supplements, per a study in the New England Journal of Medicine. If you tell your doctor everything you’re taking, she could advise you to stop a supplement that’s dangerous, pronto. “Having a discussion with your doctor about dietary supplements will help to flush out the potential risks and benefits of dietary supplements,” says Tolliver. Find out medication mistakes that could make you sick.